Main Menu
Recent News
Latest Articles
Random photos


Titanic.com - Titanic News, Photos, Articles & Research | Forum Index
   Titanic historic
   Captain Smith a criminal?

Browsing this Thread:   70 Anonymous Users

 

  Bottom    Previous Topic    Next Topic
  •  Rate Thread
      Rate this Thread
      Excellent
      Good
      Average
      Bad
      Terrible
Poster Thread Rated:  1 Votes
  •  Captain_Jack
      Captain_Jack
Re: Captain Smith a criminal?
#1

Joined: 2005/3/30
From
Posts: -1
Group:
Registered Users
Offline
Quote:

edward9139 wrote:
i do agree somewhat with you but he should hav known what the consequences could be .
well...gtg2skool
tty'all later.



I'm not sure you are stating the facts of consequences correctly! You want to blame Ismay for the sinking by wanting to show case the Titanic on her maiden vovage. There are many inportant unlaying reasons for the "hopes of a good showing". Foremost was to generate more corporate interest in a failing company such as the White Star. His desire to "showboat" could easily have been overrode by Captain Smith however it wasn't.
On the otherhand Captain Smith failed in his duties greatly in as much he was the person in charge of the Titanic with no dispute. Smith gave to order for full speed not Ismay. The ice reports were forwarded to Capt Smith not Bruce Ismay. Captain Smith was also responsible for adequating staffing enough sailors and officers during his away time from thr bridge-time. You can name many
more factors that contributed to the sinking.
Posted on: 2005/4/28 17:16
Create PDF from Post Print
Top
Subject Poster Date
     Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/3/17 0:52
     Re: Captain Smith a criminal? mjude 2005/3/18 0:01
     Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Dominican12 2005/3/18 4:33
       Re: Captain Smith a criminal? clinton 2005/3/18 10:21
       Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/3/18 16:58
         Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Martyn 2005/3/18 17:01
           Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/3/18 23:04
       Re: Captain Smith a criminal? ReefBlue 2005/3/18 23:30
         Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/3/18 23:45
         Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Johno 2005/3/19 16:03
           Re: Captain Smith a criminal? mjude 2005/3/20 0:30
           Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/3/20 11:44
             Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Mark Chirnside 2005/3/20 12:19
               Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/3/20 12:25
                 Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Mark Chirnside 2005/3/20 12:31
                   Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/3/20 12:33
                     Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Mark Chirnside 2005/3/20 12:35
                       Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/3/20 12:36
                         Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Mark Chirnside 2005/3/20 12:39
                           Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Johno 2005/3/20 13:52
                             Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/3/21 15:49
                               Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Johno 2005/3/21 16:12
                                 Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/3/21 17:31
                                   Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Martyn 2005/3/21 17:36
                                     Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Mark Chirnside 2005/3/21 17:41
                                     Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/3/21 18:12
                                       Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Mark Chirnside 2005/3/21 18:37
                                         Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/3/21 18:38
                                           Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Mark Chirnside 2005/3/21 18:42
                                             Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/3/21 18:43
                                               Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Mark Chirnside 2005/3/21 18:44
                                               Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/3/21 18:44
                                                 Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Mark Chirnside 2005/3/21 18:46
                                             Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Martyn 2005/3/21 18:44
                                               Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/3/21 18:46
                                                 Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Mark Chirnside 2005/3/21 18:48
                                                   Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Martyn 2005/3/21 18:52
                                                     Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/3/21 18:53
                                                       Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Mark Chirnside 2005/3/21 18:56
                                                         Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/3/21 18:56
                                                           Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Martyn 2005/3/21 19:00
                                                             Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/3/21 19:03
                                                               Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Martyn 2005/3/21 19:04
                                                                 Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/3/21 19:05
                                                                   Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Johno 2005/3/22 15:28
                                                                     Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Mark Chirnside 2005/3/22 17:54
                                                                       Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Johno 2005/3/22 18:14
                                                                         Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Mark Chirnside 2005/3/22 19:02
                                                                           Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/3/22 19:52
                                                                             Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Mark Chirnside 2005/3/22 19:55
                                                                               Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/3/22 19:55
                                                                                 Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Johno 2005/3/23 19:56
                                                                                   Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/4/10 13:52
                                                                                     Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Martyn 2005/4/10 13:57
                                                                                       Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/4/10 13:59
                                                                                         Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Martyn 2005/4/10 15:08
                                                                                           Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Johno 2005/4/11 11:28
                                                                                             Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/4/21 0:00
                                                                             Re: Captain Smith a criminal? TitanicExprt 2005/4/21 1:03
                                                                               Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/4/21 15:51
                                                                                 Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Johno 2005/4/21 19:28
                                                                                   Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/4/21 19:43
                                                                                     Re: Captain Smith a criminal? glen_fitzger 2005/4/28 0:23
                                                                                       Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/4/28 11:00
                                                                                         Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Captain_Jack 2005/4/28 17:16
                                                                                           Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/5/7 14:14
                                                                                             Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Captain_Jack 2005/5/7 19:36
                                                                                               Re: Captain Smith a criminal? edward9139 2005/5/8 13:29
                                                     Re: Captain Smith a criminal? Mark Chirnside 2005/3/21 18:54
     Re: Captain Smith a criminal? first_matey 2005/3/19 1:05
 Top   Previous Topic   Next Topic

 


 You cannot start a new topic.
 You can view topic.
 You cannot reply to posts.
 You cannot edit your posts.
 You cannot delete your posts.
 You cannot add new polls.
 You cannot vote in polls.
 You cannot attach files to posts.
 You cannot post without approval.



Copyright © 2006-2012 Titanic.com
Home Photos Advertise Link to us Flower Box